Writing Speculation With Evidence: What the Marilyn Monroe Play Speculations Teaches Student Journalists

Writing speculation with evidence starts with a visible boundary: every sentence either carries an attributed fact or announces itself as conjecture. The Guardian's 6 November 2026 review describes Torben Betts's Speculations, directed by Trevor Nunn at the Marylebone Theatre, as an "intriguing but flawed" drama in which journalist Dorothy Kilgallen pursues her unverified theory linking the Kennedys to Marilyn Monroe's death. We suggest treating that premise as a craft model, not a source claim: attribute each assertion, flag open questions, and let the investigator's obsession drive the narrative without endorsing her conclusions. Test each draft by marking where proof ends and speculation begins.

Stage One: Build a Claim Ledger Before You Write

A story built on unverified claims can still be assembled claim by claim, provided every assertion is tagged before the prose begins. The Guardian's 6 November 2026 review of Torben Betts's Speculations, directed by Trevor Nunn at the Marylebone Theatre, reports the chain Dorothy Kilgallen pursues: Marilyn Monroe found dead in her bed, Kilgallen's belief that both John F Kennedy and Robert F Kennedy had something to do with it, and an unpublished book linking a political cover-up and underworld crime that, she argues, led to Monroe's death aged 36. We suggest treating that chain as a craft model rather than established history: each link is either attributed to Kilgallen or left open. Our method, the claim ledger, inventories every assertion a draft will make and tags it sourced, documented, or conjecture.

We suggest running the ledger before any drafting. List every claim your story will make and give each one of three tags: sourced, where you name the person who said it; documented, where you name the record that shows it; or conjecture, where the guess is yours or your subject's. Practise on the Kilgallen chain as the review reports it, tagging her theory, her unpublished book and the cover-up link separately, then run the same pass on your own draft. The constraint is strict: anything you cannot tag gets cut or rewritten as an open question. Evaluate by swapping ledgers with a partner: can they trace every claim to its tag without asking you? Then write one paragraph from the ledger, compare it with an earlier free-written version, and count how many claims lost their source.

Stage Two: Run a Certainty Audit on Your Verbs

Uncertainty in a draft usually hides in verbs, so the second stage of our method is a close look at which verb carries each claim. The Guardian's 6 November 2026 review of Speculations offers an observable model: the reviewer writes that Dorothy Kilgallen thinks both John F Kennedy and Robert F Kennedy had something to do with Marilyn Monroe's death, and that she argues her case through an unpublished book linking a political cover-up and underworld crime. Those verbs, thinks and argues, hand the theory to Kilgallen rather than asserting it in the newspaper's own voice, so the reader always knows the claim belongs to the investigator. We treat that phrasing as a craft model to study, not as a verdict on the theory itself.

We suggest a certainty audit as our exercise. Highlight every verb that carries a claim in your draft, then sort each into attribution verbs such as thinks, argues, suspects and claims, or evidence verbs such as records, states, shows and according to. The constraint is that no claim-carrying verb may stay unsorted; anything ambiguous gets rewritten before you continue. Then rewrite five of your own sentences twice, once with the claim attributed to a named person and once tied to a named record, and read both versions aloud, marking which one you could defend if the source challenged your wording. Treat the audit as a hypothesis to test rather than a rule: compare the pairs with a partner and note where the attributed version keeps a question genuinely open instead of quietly settling it.

Stage Three: Let the Pursuit, Not the Verdict, Drive the Story

A story built on an unproven theory can still move forward, because momentum can come from what the investigator does rather than from any verdict she reaches. The Guardian's 6 November 2026 review of Torben Betts's Speculations, directed by Trevor Nunn at the Marylebone Theatre, shows this in miniature: Dorothy Kilgallen hammers at a typewriter, pursues the theory that both Kennedys had something to do with Monroe's death, and her investigations feed an unpublished book suggesting links between a political cover-up and underworld crime. Crucially, the review's summary keeps verbs such as thinks and argues attached to Kilgallen herself, so the narrative follows her pursuit without adopting her conclusion. We read this as a transferable method to test: let actions supply the drive, and let attribution supply the distance.

We suggest an exercise called engine-not-verdict. Draft a 300-word sequence built entirely on what your subject does next: the record she requests, the interview she seeks, the chapter she cannot finish. The constraint is that every theory must be attributed to her by name in the narration, echoing how the review's summary keeps Kilgallen as the one who thinks and argues; the narrator may never assert the theory in its own voice. Then write a second version in which the narrator states the same theory directly, and compare the two with a partner, asking which version lets a reader follow the obsession without inheriting the conclusion. One caution: the Guardian calls the play intriguing but flawed, yet our excerpt omits the reviewer's reasons, so resist assuming where the flaw lies; flag that gap as you would in copy.

Stage Four: Put the Proof-Line on the Page Where Readers Can See It

The proof-line is the visible boundary between documented fact and conjecture, placed on the page where readers can see it rather than kept in the writer's head. The Guardian's 6 November 2026 review of Torben Betts's Speculations, directed by Trevor Nunn at the Marylebone Theatre, reports the chain Dorothy Kilgallen pursues: Marilyn Monroe found dead in her bed, Kilgallen's belief that both John F Kennedy and Robert F Kennedy had something to do with it, and an unpublished book linking a political cover-up and underworld crime that, she argues, led to Monroe's death aged 36. The review's summary keeps the theory attached to Kilgallen through verbs such as thinks and argues, so a reader can tell which assertions belong to her and which are established. We suggest treating that separation as a page-level device: the proof-line paragraph.

We suggest a proof-line paragraph as our exercise: at the end of each section of your draft, write two sentences, one naming what is documented so far and one naming what remains unproven or unresolved. The constraint is that the two sentences must be specific, naming the record or the person, not vague hedges such as sources say. Then run a reader test: hand the draft to someone who has not seen your research and ask them to list which claims carry sources and which do not; their errors show where your boundary blurred. Finally, compare two structural choices on the same material, proof-lines after every section versus one consolidated status note at the end, and record which placement your test reader finds clearer. This is an interpretive craft move to evaluate, not a guaranteed effect, so let the comparison decide what you keep.

Sources