How to Start a Memoir: What Evan Gershkovich's Arrest Scene Teaches Student Writers

If you are wondering how to start a memoir, begin with the scene that changed everything, not a summary of your life. Open at the turning point — a phone call, a diagnosis, a door closing — and let readers feel it unfold in real time before you explain anything. Only after that scene has earned attention should you rewind to who you were before it, as Evan Gershkovich's This Cursed Beautiful Land does when it opens on his arrest in a sting operation and then returns to his New Jersey childhood between two cultures. The four stages below turn that structure into a repeatable method for your own draft.

Stage 1: Choose a turning point that fits inside an hour

The observation behind this stage comes from the Guardian's review of This Cursed Beautiful Land, which describes how Evan Gershkovich's opening section centres on one specific event: his arrest in a sting operation, after meeting a contact who promised to supply him with information about Russia's military-industrial preparations. The review calls that opening "gripping and rather moving", and its account then moves to backstory — a suburban New Jersey childhood between Russian Jewish immigrant parents, Soviet cartoons and "Krylov's fables rather than Aesop's", then nights as a New York Times editorial assistant before the Moscow Times. Our interpretation, offered as a hypothesis to test in your own drafts, is that a single bounded event can carry an opening, and that backstory earns its place once the scene has raised the question of who the writer was before it.

This first exercise is our suggestion, not a method taken from Gershkovich. Draw two columns. In the left, list moments in your life where something ended or began; in the right, note for each what you can still see, hear or touch — a room, a sentence someone said, an object in your hands. Choose the candidate with the richest concrete recall and the clearest before-and-after, then apply our test: the moment must fit inside roughly one hour of clock time. If your candidate spans months, treat it as a theme rather than a scene and keep searching. To evaluate the result, compare your top two candidates side by side and count which one yields more concrete detail without sliding into generalisation; the winner becomes your opening scene, and the runner-up may still supply later backstory.

Stage 2: Draft the scene as if it is happening now

The observation behind this stage comes from the Guardian's review of This Cursed Beautiful Land, which describes how the opening section recounts Gershkovich's arrest in a sting operation, after meeting a contact who promised to supply him with information about Russia's military-industrial preparations, and calls the result gripping and rather moving. Our interpretation, offered as a hypothesis to test, is that part of that grip comes from the arrest being presented as an event unfolding in sequence rather than summarised. The method we draw from this is to draft your own turning point in the same register, writing it as if it is happening now, so each sentence advances the moment instead of explaining it. Whether moment-by-moment detail holds attention better than summary is something your read-through should confirm or refute.

The exercise itself is our suggestion, not a technique taken from Gershkovich. Set a timer for twenty-five minutes and write your chosen scene in present tense, banning any sentence that begins with I had always, I remember, or Back then. Add our constraint that every paragraph must contain something a camera could film, such as a hand, a sound, a line of dialogue or its pointed absence. When the timer ends, underline every sentence a bystander in the room could have witnessed; if underlined lines do not outnumber explained ones, redraft. Treat this as a hypothesis to test rather than a guaranteed effect. To evaluate the result, compare the timed draft with your earlier summary version and mark which one gives more concrete, checkable detail per paragraph.

Stage 3: Earn the rewind with a question ledger

The observation behind this stage comes from the Guardian's review of This Cursed Beautiful Land, which describes how, after the gripping opening section on the sting-operation arrest, the account moves to backstory: a suburban New Jersey childhood between Russian Jewish immigrant parents, Soviet cartoons and "Krylov's fables rather than Aesop's", then nights as a New York Times editorial assistant before the Moscow Times, and a pull toward Russia that grew into love. Our interpretation, offered as a hypothesis to test, is that this rewind works because the scene has already raised questions — who is this reporter, why was he meeting a contact, why Russia — and the backstory answers them. The method we draw from this is to treat backstory as answers to the questions your scene creates, not as a chronological life summary.

This exercise is our suggestion, not a technique taken from Gershkovich. After your scene draft, reread it as a stranger and list every question a reader would genuinely ask about who you were before that day — this list is your question ledger. Then write backstory that answers only the questions readers actually asked, in their order, and apply our cap: roughly one page of backstory per three pages of scene. Cut anything the ledger did not request, however fond you are of it. To evaluate the result, check each backstory paragraph against the ledger: every paragraph should answer at least one listed question, and no listed question should remain unanswered before the memoir moves on. If a paragraph answers nothing, cut or defer it; if a question lingers, add the missing answer.

Stage 4: Test the hinge where scene becomes backstory

The observation behind this stage comes from the Guardian's review of This Cursed Beautiful Land, which describes how the opening section recounts Gershkovich's arrest in a sting operation after meeting a contact who promised to supply information about Russia's military-industrial preparations, and then moves to backstory: a suburban New Jersey childhood between Russian Jewish immigrant parents, Soviet cartoons and 'Krylov's fables rather than Aesop's', nights as a New York Times editorial assistant, and a start at the Moscow Times. Our interpretation, offered as a hypothesis to test, is that somewhere between these two movements lies a hinge — the sentence where scene gives way to explanation — and that this hinge shapes whether the rewind feels earned or like an interruption. The method we draw from this is to treat that pivot sentence as its own editing unit.

This exercise is our suggestion, not a technique taken from Gershkovich. Locate the exact sentence where your draft leaves the scene and enters backstory, then write three alternative bridge sentences, each naming one concrete detail from the scene and pointing to one detail from the backstory. Read the full draft aloud twice, once with each of your two strongest bridges, and mark every point where your attention drifts; treat each drift as evidence that the backstory arrived too early, not as a universal rule about readers. To evaluate, keep the bridge with the fewest drift marks and check it names at least one detail from each side. If you shape the draft into a creative non-fiction entry, remember CWA rules require any AI assistance to be clearly declared and submissions to reflect primarily your own contribution.

Sources