Writing Persona Poems: What Grace Nichols' Fat Black Woman Teaches Student Poets

Writing persona poems that carry identity, humor, and critique starts with a test: let a speaker's stance, not your default lyric I, decide what the poem notices. Grace Nichols, the Guyana-born winner of the 2026 RSL Pioneer prize, built her name this way: I Is a Long-Memoried Woman took the 1983 Commonwealth poetry prize and The Fat Black Woman's Poems followed the next year. The four exercises below treat her example as a hypothesis to test, not a formula. Each stage makes you build a speaker, let their diction generate images, aim jokes at a named target, and check by comparison whether the persona earns its place.

Stage 1: Build a speaker dossier before drafting

Grace Nichols winning the 2026 Royal Society of Literature Pioneer prize, a £10,000 award honouring women writers over 60 who broke through when the literary world was less open, gives student poets a fresh reason to study her method. Born in Guyana and based in Britain since 1977, Nichols made her name with I Is a Long-Memoried Woman, which took the 1983 Commonwealth poetry prize, and The Fat Black Woman's Poems the following year; her poems have been GCSE set texts for decades. Even the titles announce the craft move this stage examines: a speaker whose grammar ('I Is') and self-description ('Fat Black Woman') depart from the polite lyric I. Our working hypothesis, drawn from those titles rather than any quoted poem, is that a speaker's stance shapes what the poem notices first, and that students can test this rather than assume it.

Our suggested exercise is the stance ledger. Before drafting any lines, choose one candidate speaker from your own observed world, such as a relative, a shopkeeper or a bus driver, and fill three columns for them: what they notice first in any room; the words and phrasings they would never use; and what they find funny, and why. Then write five lines of pure observation filtered through that ledger, with no plot and no self-reference from you, the poet. To evaluate the result, write the same five observations a second time in your default lyric voice and compare the two sets line by line: which details differ, and do the differences trace back to a ledger column? Treat any difference as data about stance, not proof of quality, and keep the ledger, since later stages reuse it as a checklist.

Stage 2: Let the speaker's diction generate the images

The observation behind this stage sits in Nichols' titles themselves. I Is a Long-Memoried Woman, the 1983 Commonwealth poetry prize winner, opens with grammar a standard lyric I would not use, and The Fat Black Woman's Poems, published the following year, makes bold self-description the speaker's name. Our hypothesis, drawn from those titles rather than any quoted poem, is that such diction is not a costume applied after drafting but a generator: the way a speaker says things can decide which images the poem reaches for. A polite lyric I and a speaker with her own grammar may not simply sound different; they may notice different nouns, verbs, and places. Whether that holds for any given student poem is an open question this stage is designed to answer from evidence.

Our suggested exercise is the double draft. Take the same single observation you filtered through the stage 1 ledger and write it twice: version A in standard, grammatically careful lyric diction, and version B in the speaker's own grammar, idiom, and rhythm as you recorded them. The constraint is that only the diction changes; the observation, its events, and its setting stay fixed, so any difference you find is attributable to the voice. Then compare the two line by line and record which concrete nouns, verbs, and places each version names. Whether version B pulls in images version A lacks is an open question you answer from your own two drafts, not a promised outcome; some speakers will change the imagery, some will only change its music. Treat the recorded differences as data, weighed against the ledger.

Stage 3: Aim the humor at a named target

Stage three takes on humor, the element our teaching angle singles out for deliberate practice. The source record offers titles rather than quoted lines: The Fat Black Woman's Poems, published the year after I Is a Long-Memoried Woman won the 1983 Commonwealth poetry prize, names its speaker by three plain, bold descriptors, and Nichols' standing, freshly marked by the 2026 RSL Pioneer prize and decades as a GCSE set text, keeps these speakers in front of student readers. From such stance-heavy naming, our working interpretation, not a documented claim about any poem, is that a persona's laughter does different work when it answers a specific situation, treatment, or expectation the speaker faces than when it floats free as decoration. Whether aimed humor actually reads as critique is a hypothesis each writer tests on their own draft.

Our suggested exercise is the target line. Take the draft carried through stages one and two and, for every line written to be funny, write in the margin the specific thing it responds to: a situation, a treatment, or an expectation the speaker faces, ideally one your ledger's third column already recorded. If no target can be named, mark the line a decoration candidate, not for automatic deletion but for testing. Then produce two readings of the draft, one with the unaimed jokes kept and one with them cut, and read both aloud, listening for where the speaker's stance holds and where it thins. Record which version the ledger supports and what each funny line lost or gained. Treat that comparison as data for a revision decision, not proof of quality.

Stage 4: Verify the persona by parallel-speaker comparison

The closing stage asks the question the first three leave open: once a speaker has been built, has generated imagery, and has aimed its humor, does the persona earn its place at all? The contrast is visible in Nichols' titles themselves. I Is a Long-Memoried Woman, which took the 1983 Commonwealth poetry prize, and The Fat Black Woman's Poems, published the following year, announce speakers whose grammar and self-description depart from a standard lyric I; her poems have been GCSE set texts for decades, and the 2026 Royal Society of Literature Pioneer prize keeps that work current. Our working interpretation, drawn from those titles rather than any quoted poem, is that a persona justifies itself through lines a neutral speaker could not say; this stage turns that interpretation into an observable comparison rather than a feeling.

Our suggested exercise is the parallel speaker. Take the draft carried through stages one to three and produce a full second version spoken by a neutral, polite lyric I with no stance, using the same events and images; the constraint is that only the speaker changes, so any difference is attributable to the persona. Read the two versions side by side and mark every line that exists only in the persona version, meaning the neutral speaker could not say it without going false. Count those lines and record what they are. That count is data for a revision decision, not proof of quality: a low count may mean the persona is not yet doing work, or that the poem is naturally quiet, so weigh it against the stage 1 ledger before cutting or keeping the speaker.

Sources